Ten years ago yesterday, programmer Laszlo Hanyecz paid 10,000 Bitcoin for two Papa John’s pizzas in a trade that took place publicly on the Bitcoin Talk forum.
Bitcoin Pizza ad from 2010 | Source: BitcoinTalk.org
At the time, the transaction was largely laughed at — who would want some worthless internet coins for two steaming hot pies worth $30-40 in aggregate? But, as we now know, that was the first Bitcoin transaction for a real-world item ever.
Since then, May 22nd has been deemed “Bitcoin Pizza Day,” which cryptocurrency investors celebrate every year by buying pizza — with cryptocurrency if possible.
Laszlo’s transaction has been deemed so fundamentally important that popular crypto analyst Mati Greenspan opined that without that one transaction, BTC wouldn’t be where it is today.
Though there’s an unfortunate part of this transaction: the 10,000 Bitcoin once owned by the programmer and what could have been with that wealth.
Today, 10,000 BTC is worth just shy of $100 million at $92 million, meaning that those two pizzas “cost” $46 million a pop.
Many have joked about this — about the wealth that Laszlo could have made if he “HODLed,” but there might be an odd silver lining to this part of the story.
Related Reading: 2.2% of All Ethereum Is Long on Bitfinex: 3 Reasons Why This Could Go Wrong
The Silver Lining to the 10,000 Bitcoin Pizza Transaction
According to Nic Carter — partner at Castle Island Ventures and a co-founder of Coin Metrics — explained in a recent Twitter thread that there’s a possibility Laszlo decided to spend his BTC fortune out of guilt.
Out of guilt for what? For using his GPU to mine Bitcoin in the first instance of non-CPU BTC mining, which was largely looked down upon by Satoshi Nakamoto in a private email exchange eventually shared by Laszlo. Carter wrote:
“I’m speculating, but it’s entirely possible that a guilt-ridden Laszlo decided to disgorge some of his GPU-mined BTC by making a series of pizza transactions.”
The Coin Metrics founder backed this data by looking at blockchain data, which indicates that the pizza transaction is in line with the movement of the Bitcoin network difficulty and the emails with Satoshi. That’s to say, Laszlo made these transactions to distribute BTC to the community, rather than holding his ‘ill-gotten’ gains for himself.
This is your annual reminder that Bitcoin pizza day may well have been a consequence of Satoshi admonishing Laszlo over accumulating so many BTC from his experiments with GPU mining
— nic carter (@nic__carter) May 22, 2020
Carter’s speculation has been backed up by comments from the “Bitcoin Pizza Guy” himself.
Colin Harper reported in 2019 that when he spoke to Laszlo, he was told by the programmer that there was guilt running through Laszlo’s mind when the topic of GPU mining was brought up by Satoshi Nakamoto:
“That’s when I was like, ‘Man, I feel like I crapped up your project. Sorry, dude. He was concerned that some people might be discouraged because they can’t mine a block with a CPU. So, I stopped advertising it after that.”
Laszlo also purportedly added that he sees the transaction as a win for Bitcoin, not a loss for himself, further corroborating the narrative that the 10,000 Bitcoin transaction was anything but a mistake.
$90 Million Is Just the Start
Laszlo has largely abstracted himself from the economic implications of his transaction, yet many think that those two pizzas might be even more valuable than $90 million — and much more than $90 million at that — in the years to come.
Robert “Rich Dad” Kiyosaki, for instance, said recently that he thinks Bitcoin will be worth $75,000 in the coming three years. That would mean that the pizzas would be worth well over $500 million.
But even then, considering what Laszlo said, he wouldn’t feel bad about spending those BTC.
Related Reading: Crypto Tidbits: Satoshi Isn’t Dumping His Bitcoin, China ‘Bans’ Cryptocurrency Mining
Featured Image from Shutterstock origin »
Police have apprehended two crypto investors who were allegedly involved in the kidnapping and torturing of an Italian man in a Manhattan townhouse. The victim claimed his captors forced him to reveal his Bitcoin account password. According to a recent…
The price of Bitcoin has not had the most straightforward performance in 2024 despite a strong start to the year. The flagship cryptocurrency has spent most of the last two quarters in consolidation, fluctuating within the $50,000 and $70,000 range.
An analyst has explained how Bitcoin is forming both a death cross and TD sell signal, which may lead to potential dips in these targets. Bitcoin Looking In Trouble As 12-Hour Chart Forms Two Bearish Signals In a new post on X, analyst Ali discussed two signals that have recently formed in Bitcoin’s 12-hour chart.
Two Estonians were arrested for allegedly committing crypto fraud worth over $575 million
The accused are the figures behind now-defunct Bitcoin cloud-mining service provider - HashFlare
TheThe post FBI seeks victims of defunct Bitcoin mining platform as two arrested appeared first on AMBCrypto.
Santiment’s analysis suggests that Bitcoin’s fall is due to the $15,000 level for the first time in two years due to factors of fear, uncertainty, and doubt.
Bitcoin and Ether continue to struggle as they trade around $48k and $3,800 respectively on Friday. The leading cryptocurrency is now testing a key technical level that has been acting as a floor for Bitcoin over the past two years.
Bitcoin (BTC) is attempting to break out from a short-term descending resistance line. Doing so would confirm that the correction is complete.
The post Bitcoin MACD Shines Bullish Signal After Nearly Two Months appeared first on BeInCrypto.
With the Bitcoin price hitting one high after another in quick succession, you’re probably also planning on growing the size of your BTC stash. There are two ways to go about this — you can either buy Bitcoin with cash or mine it yourself.
The precious metal gold and its digital counterpart, Bitcoin, have been in a safe haven arms race for two-plus years now. The two assets became even more tightly correlated starting on Black Thursday, as investors scrambled searching for the best hedge against inflation.
After trading sideways for several months, Bitcoin may be ready to not only break out of the trading range but also break out from its multi-year triangle pattern. However, bulls must beware of the latest push beyond $10,000 triggering not one, but two sell setups on the same indicator on BTCUSD daily price charts. Bitcoin […]
Bitcoin cooled off after jumping to its highest levels in nearly two months, when it was up as much as $9,478. Yet, stakeholders say crypto interest remains strong.
Bitcoin price has fallen to $7,700 after trading above $10,000 just two weeks prior. But why exactly as Bitcoin plunged as much as 25% in a little more than two week’s time? Here are a number of factors influencing the latest cryptocurrency market bloodbath.
In less than two weeks, the Bitcoin network produced three blocks that did not propagate. The mining anomaly did not create double-spends. Bitcoin Stale Blocks Accelerate on Peak Mining Activity Bitcoin (BTC) is designed with the possibility to discover two blocks at the same time, though this is a relatively rare event.
Bitcoin's movement in the market has been keeping investors on the edge of their seats. Bitcoin's price lost 6. 76% of its value in just two days, bringing it down to $8,821. 03, at press time.
Love it or hate it, twitter is an integral part of the crypto scene. Sentiment is often gauged by reaction from Bitcoin market analysts and industry insiders who spend their time on the social media platform.
John Griffin and Amin Shams, two well-known forensic researchers, have built on their previous research which accused Tether (USDT) of single-handedly causing the 2017 bitcoin rally. According to research shared with Bloomberg, the two have found that when BTC decreased in a certain increment on Bitfinex, one single whale exerted enough orderbook pressure to flipRead MoreRead More.
Today marks the second anniversary of the User-Activated Hard Fork, which split the Bitcoin community into two competing currencies. While there have been many forks since then, none have been as successful or long-lived as Bitcoin Cash (BCH).
Fraud in the cryptocurrency industry is one of the sorest subjects, and the recent theft at the hands of two Nigerian nationals has not helped the case. TNW Hard Fork recently reported on these two fraudsters that have managed to complete multiple Bitcoin investments scams, taking $50,000 in Bitcoin from the hands of investors. Even […]
According to an official notification published April 24, 2019, by the U. S. Department of Justice for Oregon, two Nigerian nationals have been charged in a 13-count indictment with regard to their alleged involvement in an online bitcoin fraud scheme.
A United States court has sentenced Jacob Burrell Campos to two years imprisonment for operating a Bitcoin exchange business that sold hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of bitcoin without registering with the relevant financial authorities as a money transmitter.
Explaining Bitcoin to someone who knows nothing about Bitcoin isn’t easy. In fact it’s fiendishly tricky. Describing concepts such as blockchain, decentralized networks, and permissionless ledgers to beginners is as tough as describing the color orange to a blind person or the taste of an orange to someone who’s never peeled one.
The United States government has announced sanctions on two bitcoin addresses which they claim belong to two Iranians who, the government says, assisted in exchanging bitcoin ransom payments into Iranian fiat.
Yesterday, the Bitcoin Cash (BCH) blockchain split in two separate networks, each kicking off a new cryptocurrency. Now that Bitcoin Cash has forked into two rivalling cryptocurrencies – BAB, maintained by Bitcoin-ABC, and BSV, maintained by Craig Wright’s nChain – it remains to be seen which network will surface as the dominant chain.
Over the past few weeks, Bitcoin Cash supporters have been debating the upcoming hard fork scheduled for November 15th of this year. Most of the community understands, that as of right now, there are two camps that have entirely different visions.
Yesterday was the first decent day for Bitcoin in the past two weeks. Bitcoin has suffered a steep drop of nearly 30% from $8500 to almost $6100. After meeting some support near the $6100 mark, Bitcoin bounced yesterday to almost $6600.
Bitcoin has been associated with criminal activities for a long time now and while the crypto community has refuted such claims, an increasing number of instances involving the use of Bitcoin in crime suggest otherwise.
Hayden Otto has taken his enthusiasm for bitcoin as a form of currency and peer-to-peer electronic cash to new levels. He’s gone from a curious admirer to full on defender, in fact, producing two compelling videos.
Atomic Wallet, a custody-free multi-assets wallet with a decentralized exchange that supports atomic swaps, have announced that they will be adding support for Monero within 2 weeks. On their official Twitter handle, they said: “Let’s make a bet! We will add @monero to @atomicwallet in two weeks. And for on-chain anonymous $BTC – $XMR #AtomicSwap […]
Andreessen Horowitz has launched a $300 million crypto fund dedicated to investing in cryptocurrencies and other blockchain-related projects. The fund, named a16z crypto, signals that the firm is diving deeper into the cryptocurrency space to grow its existing portfolio, which includes digital currency exchange Coinbase.
A Federal Trade Commission official claimed that cryptocurrency scams looted investors of $532 million in the first two months of 2018 and predicted that the total loss could inflate to $3 billion by the end of the year.
ET 11 COMMENTS If Calvin Coolidge’s observation that “advertising is the life of trade” remains true, the new bans by Google and Facebook on cryptocurrency ads threaten the fledgling industry’s existence.
Six fully-licensed Japanese cryptocurrency exchanges have responded to the business improvement orders issued by the country’s top financial regulator. Two executives have also resigned from their positions as vice presidents of the recently formed crypto exchange association.
The Chinese mining company Bitmain now controls over 40% of the BTC hashing power. This means that the company is approaching the hashing power required to control the Bitcoin network and – if it pleased – stage a 51% attack.
Witek Radomski — co-founder and CTO of Enjin Coin — has developed ERC-1155, a new standard for defining video game tokens on the Ethereum blockchain. Radomski’s journey to improve the gaming experience began 12 months ago in June 2017, when he created code for the first non-fungible token.
The China Center for Information Industry Development (CCID) released the second iteration of its monthly Global Public Chain Technology Evaluation Index. As part of the Ministry of Industry and Technology Information, the CCID is releasing the monthly reports on behalf of the Chinese government.
At press time, the father of cryptocurrencies has incurred a $200 rise and is now trading for roughly $6,300. This marks some good news for investors and traders, who up to this point, have probably lost some serious cash after bitcoin fell by over $1,500 in just the last two weeks. In early June, the […]
Bitcoin price failed to recover above $107,000. BTC is trimming gains and might could continue to move down if it trades below $102,500. Bitcoin started a fresh decline after it failed to clear $107,000.
Square, the payment services arm of Block, has launched its Bitcoin payment feature for small businesses, allowing them to accept BTC payments and manage their digital assets alongside traditional finances through its point-of-sale platform.
Eric Trump, son of US President Donald Trump and executive vice president of the Trump Organization, has revealed new bullish predictions for Bitcoin (BTC).
Bitcoin price is attempting to recover above $103,500. BTC could continue to move up if it clears the $106,500 resistance zone. Bitcoin started a decent recovery wave above the $103,500 support. The price is trading above $104,500 and the 100 hourly Simple moving average.
Bitcoin price is struggling below $105,000. BTC could continue to move down if it stays below the $104,200 resistance. Bitcoin started a fresh decline below the $104,000 support. The price is trading below $104,000 and the 100 hourly Simple moving average.
