The court battle between the United States SEC and Telegram takes place today in New York. While both sides maintain their positions over the legality of the $1.7bn token offering, the greater blockchain space anxiously watches on.
SEC Says Telegram Violated Securities Laws
The SEC case against Telegram is, without doubt, the largest and most pivotal so far. The outcome could mark a turning point for the blockchain industry.
It’s one of the few times that SEC action concerning federal securities laws and digital tokens could head to trial. Partner and Litigator at FisherBroyles LLP Rebecca Rettig told Law360:
Given the size of the offering and the different players here… I think this will be a seminal case going forward.
If the hammer falls in favor of the SEC, Telegram will have to pay a substantial fine. The company may even have to return the $1.7bn to investors.
If the court rules that Telegram did not break the securities’ law, it will be able to launch its network on TON and distribute the overdue Gram tokens to investors.
The SEC initially brought the suit against Telegram last October. It maintains that Telegram violated the Securities Act of 1933 with its token offering by not adhering to registration requirements.
Telegram was also forced to postpone delivery of around 2.9 billion Grams to their investors, which should have been available on the TON blockchain by Oct 31.
U.S. District Judge P. Kevin Castel will decide the outcome of the SEC vs Telegram case as he hears from both sides today.
Telegram Maintains It Did Not Act Illegally
Telegram, for its part, maintains that no such violation took place. For starters, the messaging app claims that the SEC is referring to the investment contracts it sold for Gram tokens rather than the underlying tokes which, when issued, will be commodities. This means that Gram purchasers will “have no expectation of profits based”.
Moreover, the investment contracts were issued pursuant to securities exemption Regulation D. Therefore, the SEC’s argument over whether Telegram’s Gram tokens are securities is a moot point since Telegram already conducted the sale according to exemptions under the Securities Act.
While no final resolution is expected today, the way in which Judge Castel poses his questions may give some indication as to which way he is likely to rule. Partner at Munger Tolles & Olson LLP told Law360:
The most you’re going to see is an indication based on questions of where the judgment might go… I do expect the judge to try to rule fairly quickly if he thinks that the [preliminary injunction] should be denied.
A Precedent for Token Issuers in the U.S.
Ever since the ICO boom of 2017 and early 2018, token issuers have been scrambling to understand the legal situation in the states. Yet, some three years later, uncertainty still reigns supreme.
The SEC has certainly been more vocal on the subject of ICOs and killed unregulated offerings moving forward. It has also flagged up and fined several companies in the space, most notably BlockOne for its EOS token sale.
However, in early 2018, there was little clarity on regulatory requirements in the U.S. for issuing tokens. This has prompted many in the crypto industry to come out in favor of Telegram, including the Chamber of Digital Commerce and the Blockchain Association.
They cite the lack of regulatory clarity by the SEC over its treatment of digital assets. There is a deep concern that “regulation by enforcement” could be highly detrimental to the blockchain industry as a whole.
Many people will be watching the case closely. How Judge Castel rules will likely set a precedent moving forward. It could either send innovation offshore forcing U.S. companies to friendlier jurisdictions or if Telegram wins, be seen as a win for the crypto community at large.
Who do you think will win in this legal battle? Let us know in the comments below!
Images via Shutterstock origin »
India’s supreme court spent all day on Wednesday hearing extensive arguments from both the counsel representing crypto exchanges and the central bank, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The counsel for the central bank confirmed again that cryptocurrency is not banned in India, but still justifies the banking restrictions on the crypto industry.
The three-judge bench of the Supreme Court of India reconvened today to hear the 'Crypto v. RBI' case after the last hearing took place way back in August 2019. At the previous hearing, there were argThe post India: RBI doesn't want blockchain to undermine faith, trust in digital payments appeared first on AMBCrypto.
A Danish court today ruled that Nordea Bank Danmark A/S has the right to say whether its employees can invest in Bitcoin. The bank first introduced a policy prohibiting crypto purchases last year.
Верховный суд Индии перенес на январь слушание о запрете Резервного банка (RBI) на предоставление услуг компаниям и частным лицам, связанным с биткоином и другими цифровыми валютами. #Crypto v. #RBI Case adjourned for 14.
The British Columbia Securities Commission (BCSC), announced today it has taken action to protect customers of Einstein Exchange, a crypto-asset trading platform based in Vancouver. On November 1st, the BCSC applied to the Supreme Court of British Columbia for an order appointing an interim receiver to preserve and protect any assets of Einstein Exchange.
The FTX cryptocurrency derivatives exchange has just been hit with a $150 million lawsuit in the United States District Court for the northern district of California. The lawsuit was filed earlier today (Nov 3) by plaintiff Bitcoin Manipulation Abatement LLC.
Efforts by Wikileaks founder Julian Assange to fight extradition to the US are in high gear ahead of his court appearance today. Assange who has been in the custody of the UK police since being arrested in April has vowed to fight the extradition ‘as long as it takes’.
The Supreme Court of India on Tuesday once again postponed hearing the case against the crypto banking restrictions by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The central bank has replied to crypto exchanges’ representation as directed by the court, which was supposed to resume hearing the case today.
The Supreme Court of India has set a new date to resume hearing the arguments against the crypto banking restrictions by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). The central bank has replied to crypto exchanges’ representation as directed by the court, which was supposed to resume hearing the case today.
For more information like this, make sure to subscribe to ZeroNoncense's Telegram and follow them on Twitter. As noted in their previous post outlining the fundamentals of the press release by the SEC, the actual pdf for the order, which was submitted by the SEC to the Manhattan Supreme Court today can be found here: […]
The US Supreme Court today officially declined an appeal from Amazon that would’ve protected the company from facing a Nevada state court over a labor suit SCOTUS itself ruled on more than five years ago.
In mid-January this year, popular New Zealand crypto exchange, Cryptopia announced its hack which saw users lose crypto assets valued at $16 million USD (which could currently be much higher). After several investigations, court proceedings and pleas for bankruptcy in the U.
A federal appeals court today ruled to uphold the FCC‘s 2017 repeal of net neutrality laws, meaning Ajit Pai’s rollback of the Obama-era laws will stand. However, the court did offer an avenue for those who wish to try getting it reinstated in their state, because it turns out the FCC doesn’t have the authority to ban that.
Bitcoin has fallen slightly today by about -2%, while pound is up against the euro by about 0.36%. That’s while the legal world woke up to a metaphorical earthquake as...
The post Bitcoin Falls, Pound Up as Court Rules Boris Acted Unlawfully appeared first on Trustnodes.
Ted Livingston, Founder of Kik Messenger, is in the news after in a blog post today he announced that that the company would be shutting down operations after repeated court disputes with the SEC over centralization concerns with regards to their cryptocurrency, Kin.
An appeals court situated in California, US, today said it’s not illegal to scrape data from public websites without any prior approval. Web scraping refers to the process of collecting large troves of data with the use of web crawlers – scripts designed to lift information from web pages.
India’s top-most court has given the country’s central bank two weeks to justify its decision to ban crypto business in the country. #Crypto v. #RBI Hearing of Crypto case has resumed. Mr. Shyam Divan, Ld.
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) did not correctly respond to the presentation that could have removed the necessity of banning bitcoin trading in the country, found the apex court. The Supreme Court of India noted in a hearing today that the central bank forwarded the presentation to the government.
The courtroom battle between India’s bitcoin exchanges and the central bank appears to go in favor of the former. In a hearing today, the Supreme Court judge asked the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) that why it chose to ban bitcoin trading when it could regulate it.
The Supreme Court of India today resumed the ‘Internet and Mobile Association of India vs RBI’ case hearing. Continuing from its last hearing on the 14th of August, IAMAI Counsel, Ashim Sood, today argued that the action of the Reserve Bank of India was against the “doctrine of proportionality,” besides being based on no study […]
The post India: Central Bank’s circular on cryptocurrencies void on the basis of vagueness, claims counsel before the SC appeared first on AMBCrypto.
The Indian supreme court resumed hearing the writ petitions against the banking restriction by the central bank, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), on Wednesday. Many issues were discussed, ranging from the legality of the RBI action to the classification of crypto assets and how each country regulates them.
The Indian supreme court finally heard the crypto case today after postponing it several times. The court addressed the government’s crypto policy as well as the writ petitions challenging the banking restriction by the central bank.
The Indian supreme court finally heard the crypto case today after postponing it several times. The court addressed the government’s crypto policy as well as the writ petitions challenging the banking restriction by the central bank.
Bitcoin SV creator Craig Wright claimed that he created Bitcoin as Satoshi Nakamoto—Bitcoin Cash founder Roger Ver called him a fraud. The two took the matter to court, and today, England’s high court ruled in favor of Ver.
Bitcoin SV creator Craig Wright claimed that he created Bitcoin as Satoshi Nakamoto—Bitcoin Cash founder Roger Ver called him a fraud. The two took the matter to court, and today, England’s high court ruled in favor of Ver.
A UK judge has dismissed a defamation case filed by Craig Steven Wright, Bitcoin‘s self-proclaimed creator, against Bitcoin Cash advocate Roger Ver. The case was thrown out of court on grounds that it was “weak,” “lacking in detail,” and “inappropriate.
Суд города Ханчжоу, специализирующийся на рассмотрении дел, связанных с цифровыми данными в интернете, признал биткоин «виртуальной собственностью». Об этом сообщила партнер фирмы Primitive Дави Ван со ссылкой на местные СМИ.
Markets are up today with good regulatory vibes following positive reactions from a number of American Senators who successfully distinguished Bitcoin from the much-maligned Libra. Traders witnessed Bitcoin jumping 10% in about an hour, a leap similar to that seen at the beginning of the bull rally back in April of this year.
Markets are up today with good regulatory vibes following positive reactions from a number of American Senators who successfully distinguished Bitcoin from the much-maligned Libra. Traders witnessed Bitcoin jumping 10% in about an hour, a leap similar to that seen at the beginning of the bull rally back in April of this year.
A US federal court has ruled today that President Donald Trump can’t block his haters on Twitter. The United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit situated in New York said that since Trump uses the social network to communicate matters related to government affairs, he can’t bar some Americans from accessing that information.
Disgraced football coach Mark “Bomber” Thompson has admitted to abusing crystal meth and obsessively trading cryptocurrency for 12 hours a day in the lead-up to his arrest, reports the Sydney Morning Herald.
The creator of the Big Brother reality television format is suing Facebook for allowing advertisements to fraudulently feature his name and image, Reuters reports. Dutch billionaire John de Mol, one of the brains behind entertainment studio Endemol, filed his suit against Facebook in an Amsterdam court earlier today.
In a turn everyone should’ve seen coming, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is suing messaging app Kik for its initial coin offering (ICO). In court documents released yesterday, the SEC outlined that Kik’s sale of one trillion “Kin” tokens was not registered with the SEC.
October 1, 2018, marked five years since I was imprisoned. My physical surroundings today are ironically similar to what they were after my arrest back in 2013. I’m in the SHU again (Special Housing Unit, aka “the hole”).
An Australian government employee will reportedly face court today over his alleged misuse of government IT systems to mine cryptocurrency for personal gain
An Australian government employee is appearing in court today after using work equipment to mine cryptocurrency for his own gain. The Australian Federal Police (AFP) allege that the 33 year-old from Killara in New South Wales took advantage of his position as an IT contractor to modify government computer systems to mine cryptocurrency.
A prominent U. S.-based lawyer, Stephen Palley, who works at Anderson Kill, has recently decided to talk about the FLiK token, a court case that is happening right now. Unlike most of the tokens which are being talked about in the crypto space today, FLiK was backed by a celebrity, which is one of the […]
Bitfinex is forging forward despite its ongoing row with the authorities, and it's looking for investors to support its efforts. Today, May 8, 2019, iFinex, the operator and parent company of the popular cryptocurrency exchange, released a private token sale white paper, putting to rest rumors of its Initial Exchange Offering (IEO).
By CCN. com: The Mt. Gox trustee, who is in charge of distributing what remains of Mt. Gox’s assets to claimants, also known as “creditors,” put in for an extension on the filing deadline, which would have been today.
By CCN: In what may be considered a tacit admission of guilt, Craig Wright’s attorneys have requested that “exhibit A,” an e-mail that was proven to be fake, be withdrawn from evidence in a lawsuit filed against Wright by Dave Kleiman’s estate.
According to a report today from the Metropolitan Police Service (MPS), London’s Territorial police force, the Wikileaks Co-Founder Julian Assange has been arrested by officers from the Metropolitan Police Service at the Ecuadorian embassy in London, SW1.
London’s Metropolitan Police has arrested Julian Assange after Ecuador’s government withdrew his asylum. According to a press release from the Met, Assange was arrested within Ecuador’s London Embassy, where the WikiLeaks founder has lived for almost seven years.
It’s shaping up to be a rough day for Elon Musk. Shares at his Tesla were down sharply this morning on horrific Q1 delivery numbers. Those numbers came out as the CEO readies to learn his faith resulting from being held in contempt of court for violating an agreement with the U.
India’s supreme court has postponed hearing the crypto case at the request of the government’s counsel. The court was expecting to hear about the country’s cryptocurrency regulation today before proceeding to address the banking ban by the central bank.
A Japanese web designer has been given the right to walk, despite “borrowing” the computing power of unsuspecting users to mine cryptocurrency. The 31-year-old web designer appeared in court today and was acquitted of stealing his user’s computing resources with a Monero mining script called Coinhive, local news outlet The Mainichi reports.
One thing you won’t be able to use Facebook’s new WhatsApp cryptocurrency for is buying or selling revenge porn on the social media platform. Facebook, the company revealed today, just made an AI that’s an expert on porn.
CipherTrace, a blockchain security company, announced today that its CEO, Dave Jevans, has been certified by a Canadian criminal court as an expert witness. Jevans testified against Matthew Phan, a drug dealer convicted for trafficking in drugs and weapons on the dark web.
CipherTrace, a blockchain forensics company, makes headlines today for its role in the seizure of $1. 4 million in bitcoins that may have been destined for illicit usage. In the resulting court case, David Jevans, CEO of CipherTrace was called upon to serve as the first ever Bitcoin expert witness.
Verb holds $713 million in Toncoin and $67 million in cash reserves. Ledger Live integration allows TON staking from just 10 tokens. TON Sharpe ratio turned positive in August, indicating momentum.
С утра понедельника Toncoin ощутимо просел на -5%, вернувшись к $2,79 после локального хайпа, который разогнали сами же его разработчики… Ситуация показательная и полезная для всех! Глава TON Foundation, Макс Краун, в воскресенье выкатил в X пост с заявлением о том, что если застейкать TON на $100к на три года и заплатить $35к комиссии, то […]
Материал TON и «Золотая виза» в ОАЭ – FAKE появился сначала на WHATTONEWS – Новости криптовалют.
The Open Platform (the first Telegram Web3 unicorn) raises $28.5M to expand TON-based products, crypto wallets, and AI-powered blockchain apps globally.
