Researcher’s Scathing Lightning Network Analysis Finds Flaws

Researcher’s Scathing Lightning Network Analysis Finds Flaws
ôîòî ïîêàçàíî ñ : news.bitcoin.com

2020-1-9 19:00

On January 7, digital preservation researcher David Rosenthal published an overview of BTC’s Lightning Network (LN) which claims LN infrastructure isn’t decentralized and privacy-preservation is a myth. Rosenthal’s analysis found significant flaws with the LN fee system and the editorial insists “in order for Lightning Network to provide privacy, it must be massively over-capitalized.”

Also read: Here’s What Happens When You Use Lightning Network for the First Time

Digital Preservation Researcher David Rosenthal Investigates Lightning Network

The controversial scaling solution called the Lightning Network has a bunch of fans and a slew of detractors as well. A number of people think that a second layer is required to scale BTC to the masses, while other individuals wholeheartedly believe layer one (onchain transactions) should be sufficient. Since 2015, the scaling debate over this subject has continued relentlessly and despite a variety of reports disclosing LN vulnerabilities, BTC supporters remain confident the solution will succeed.

On Tuesday, digital preservation analyst David Rosenthal published his thoughts on the LN scaling solution. Rosenthal’s “DSHR’s Blog” has been publishing reports on technology and digital preservation since 2007. Rosenthal notes in his recent piece that crypto and blockchain discussions often involve theories that are hoped to be realized in practice. LN advocates claim that the system will enhance decentralization and anonymity. Rosenthal asserts that the LN system doesn’t work and that it’s not really decentralized. Moreover, the researcher highlights that “transaction fees [are] woefully inadequate to cover the costs of running a node.” Rosenthal cites a paper written by a Hungarian team of researchers called “A Cryptoeconomic Traffic Analysis of Bitcoin’s Lightning Network.”

Source: “A Cryptoeconomic Traffic Analysis of Bitcoin’s Lightning Network.”

“As usual, Bitcoin enthusiasts are taken in by the hype,” Rosenthal writes. “[The Hungarian researchers] built a simulation and calibrated it against the public information they could find about the Lightning Network. Experiments they ran using their simulation led them to conclude that the “negligible fees” are massively subsidized by the large Lightning nodes.” Rosenthal adds that most transactions pay roughly 10% of the cost of their routing, which could potentially work in a different context. The researcher adds:

This greater than Uber level of subsidy could make business sense only in the context of investing in a future monopoly capable of massively raising prices. But prices are capped by transaction fees on the Bitcoin blockchain, making it impossible.

The Elephant in the Room: Routing Issues

Rosenthal’s post also highlights the Hungarian researchers’ simulation, which shows out of 7,000 transactions per day, one third fail. “This is not a practical payment system,” the author emphasized. The paper also mentions the often cited routing problem and in Rosenthal’s opinion, LN’s dynamic routing is an “exceptionally difficult computational problem.” Additionally, the post details that the Cryptoeconomic Traffic Analysis paper draws attention to LN’s routing issues. “Even in theory, the combination of source and onion routing provides a fairly weak version of privacy,” Rosenthal remarked.

Source: Mathematical Proof That the Lightning Network Cannot Be a Decentralized Bitcoin Scaling Solution by Jonald Fyookball.

“In other words, in order for Lightning Network to provide privacy, it must be massively over-capitalized,” Rosenthal’s post concludes. “If fees are high enough that running a router node is economically rational, privacy cannot be provided because the additional hops needed would both be too expensive and would increase the already high probability of transaction failure.”

What do you think about David Rosenthal’s analysis of the Lightning Network? Let us know what you think about this subject in the comments section below.

Image credits: Shutterstock, Pixabay, Wiki Commons, Research paper 1, Research paper 2, and Fair Use.

Did you know you can verify any unconfirmed Bitcoin transaction with our Bitcoin Block Explorer tool? Simply complete a Bitcoin address search to view it on the blockchain. Plus, visit our Bitcoin Charts to see what’s happening in the industry.

The post Researcher’s Scathing Lightning Network Analysis Finds Flaws appeared first on Bitcoin News.

Similar to Notcoin - Blum - Airdrops In 2024

origin »

Santiment Network Token (SAN) íà Currencies.ru

$ 0.0865709 (-0.22%)
Îáúåì 24H $210
Èçìåíåèÿ 24h: 9.95 %, 7d: 19.49 %
Cåãîäíÿ L: $0.0865709 - H: $0.0865709
Êàïèòàëèçàöèÿ $0 Rank 5672
Öåíà â ÷àñ íîâîñòè $ 0.5208 (-83.38%)

network researcher lightning claims btc infrastructure decentralized

network researcher → Ðåçóëüòàòîâ: 46


Ethereum’s Transition to Proof Of Staking In Version 2.0 Scheduled For Q1 of 2020

According to crypto news sources, the first stage of the Ethereum network’s transition to Ethereum 2.0 is expected to take place in January of 2020. In a recent podcast, Danny Ryan who is a researcher at the Ethereum Foundation explained on the new sharding proposal will allow for a reduction for the amount of shards […]

2019-11-18 19:48


Ethereum’s Token Reduction to Take Hold by 2021, Researcher Affirms

Justin Drake, an Ethereum researcher, has recently talked about the upcoming developments which will happen on Ethereum during the process to create the so-called Ethereum 2.0 phase of the system. According to him, the network might decrease tenfold the issuance of new tokens starting in 2021. He even laid out a possible timeline for the […]

2019-7-6 03:37


Data Breach Report From Instagram Raises Concerns About Upcoming Facebook’s Digital Currency

Facebook, the most popular social network in the world, has been affected by different data leaks over the last years. This has harmed users and individuals that had data stored on their platform. Now, the security researcher Anurag Sen discovered that there was a public Amazon Web Services (AWS) database that had the information of […]

2019-5-21 18:33


Monero needs to throw away bulletproof tech and deploy enormous ring signatures, claims Blockstream researcher

Monero network relies on ring signature, ring confidential transactions, and stealth addresses for the purpose of anonymity. Talking about swapping the cryptographic operation of ring signature in Monero, Andrew Poelstra, Blockstream Director of Research, in a recent interview on the sidelines of Magical Crypto Conference, said that he knows some of the ideas that have been “thrown […] The post Monero needs to throw away bulletproof tech and deploy enormous ring signatures, claims Blockstream researcher appeared first on AMBCrypto.

2019-5-15 20:30


Crypto Researcher Report Covers Latest Lightning Network (LN) Concerns About Peak Capacity

Over the course of the past few weeks, the debate surrounding LN’s scaling potential has come to the forefront once again. While many have argued that the Lightning Network’s intrinsic framework is flawed and ridden with loopholes, recent data seems to suggest that the network has continued to grow and that its capacity is currently […]

2019-4-24 19:08


Ôîòî:

Facebook may soon let you chat with friends on mobile without Messenger

Five years ago, Facebook began encouraging users to use its standalone Messenger app to chat with their contacts, instead of using the built-in feature in the social network’s mobile apps. It appears that it’s now looking to bring messaging back to the primary Facebook app experience – which indicates a change in strategy for keeping users engaged on the platform App researcher Jane Manchun Wong tweeted a screenshot of a Facebook feature in the works, which shows a new tab for messaging people right within the social network’s app.

2019-4-12 10:48


Ôîòî:

Making ATM Bitcoin Payments via Lightning Network Is Becoming a Reality

Developer and researcher Felix Weis successfully executed, as a proof-of-concept, the world’s first ATM Bitcoin transaction on the Lightning Network. World’s First Lightning-enabled Bitcoin ATM ‘Worked Fine’ On March 31, 2019, Weis publicly demonstrated a transaction via Lightning Network at a bitcoin ATM, during the Lightning Hackday, in Hong Kong, as shown in the video below.

2019-4-1 21:30


Emerging Markets Are the Biggest Determinant of Bitcoin’s Price Movement: Fundstrat’s Tom Lee

Mining and network effects affect the price of Bitcoin, but according to Tom Lee, the biggest determinant of Bitcoin’s price movement is the emerging markets. In a recent interview, the Bitcoin researcher from Fundstrat Global Advisors stated that the economic factors at play in emerging markets have had the biggest effect on the price of […]

2018-8-30 01:00


Research Associate: Conversations Around Bitcoin and Energy Have Been Oversimplified

In the almost decade long existence of Bitcoin, the network has repeatedly come under fire for the large amount of electricity required to secure it. However, one researcher believes that the current discussion on energy use is largely redundant since it doesn’t take into account how the electricity itself is sourced or how technology evolves.

2018-8-20 22:30


Cardano [ADA] – Ouroboros protocol versions explained by IOHK’s Peter Gazi

On 26th July, IOHK published a video, in which Dr. Peter Gazi, a researcher of the foundation explains two specific versions of Ouroboros protocols and how they relate to each other. According to him, the first Ouroboros protocol was published in the year 2017, which is presently underlying the implementation of the Cardano network. However, soon other […]

2018-8-3 02:46


Ôîòî:

Facebook is teaching AI to talk you through directions

Facebook is developing a “Talk the Walk” AI capable of giving walking directions without knowing a user’s location. What it is: A team comprised of a researcher from the University of Montreal in Canada and Facebook Artificial Intelligence Research (FAIR) scientists recently published a white paper describing a neural network capable of giving a person plain language directions without the use of GPS or other location tracking aids.

2018-7-11 19:00